[PREV - WRONG_TO_THE_CORE]    [TOP]

NUCLEAR_BERN


                                             September 25, 2019  
                                                                 
    On nuclear power, an area where many a                       
    presidential candidate has it wrong in my                    
    opinion, the wrongest of the bunch is                        
    Bernie Sanders.                                              
                                                                 
    His policy statement calls for a moratorium                  
    on nuclear plant license *renewals*: he                      
    really wants to shut 'em all down.               WRONG_TO_THE_CORE
                                                                 
                                                                 
         I really like Bernie Sanders, I like                    
         what he's done for US politics, but on                  
         this one though he's so wrong he                 
         has me wondering about him, and looking                 
         for other options.                                      
                                                                 
         When it was pointed out to him that                     
         New Hampshire's carbon footprint went                   
         up when they closed the Vermont                         
         Yankee plant, he responded curtly                       
         "I don't believe that."                                 
                                                                 
            But you know, data and studies and                   
            all that right?  We like that                        
            scientific stuff, don't we?                          
                                                                 
            Denialism doesn't get any prettier                   
            when it comes from the left.                         
                                                                 
                                                                 
   There's a standard "moderate" criticism of Bernie             
   Sanders that essentially accuses him of being an              
   inflexible fanatic that doesn't understand how to             
   use political compromise to get things done...                
                                                                 
   I've always been pretty skeptical of that one:                
   it seems to me that someone who's survived in                 
   the Senate for decades and has a reputation as                
   "the Amendment King" probably knows something                 
   about pragmatic compromise.                                   
                                                                 
   This one has the alarm bells ringing though--                 
   it's a holdover of the bad craziness the left                 
   seemed afflicted with in the 70s.  He's going                 
   for broke to win a tribal battle, without                     
   regard for reason or consequences...                          
                                                                 
                                                                 
     I'm currently thinking about                                
     switching to Elizabeth                    Elizabeth Warren's on-line
     Warren... she's also anti-nuclear,        policy says nothing at all
     but somewhat less deranged about          about nuclear power, though
     it.  My impression of her is she's        there's one occasion where
     someone capable of listening to           she asserted there will be
     reason and revising her opinions--        no new nukes built when
     e.g. she started out as a                 she's president.  
     Republican a few decades back.                              
                                               She's in favor of the
     I am politely (okay, I'm                  "Green New Deal", which in
     lying) ignoring Joe Biden,                itself ambiguous about
     who is pro-nuclear, but                   whether nuclear power is
     isn't really a serious                    green.  There are a few
     candidate-- we can only hope              places where Warren says
     the Democratic primary                    "renewable" when she
     voters notice this soon.                  should've said "clean".
                                                                 
         Biden's policy statement                  In any case, there's a 
         calls for research into                   huge difference between 
         new nuclear power designs.                "no new" and "shut down
                                                   the old".     
                                                                 
     As of this writing, there                                       
     are some other half-way                                         
     reasonable more-or-less                                         
     pro-nuclear candidates--                                         
     notably, Buttigieg and                                           
     Booker-- but they're on                                         
     the death watch list, or                                        
     close to it.                                                    
           
     
     
     
--------
[NEXT - ANTI_NUCLEAR_CLOWN]