[PREV - ZENITH_ANGLE]    [TOP]

MODERN_FORGERS


                                                 May 20, 2006

Jonathan Gash - "The Rich and the Profane" (1998) 
   
One of the series about the              
character Lovejoy, an "antique               
dealer" with a psychic ability        The idea seems to be that Lovejoy    
to detect genuine antiques, who       is the real thing, a man with 
never-the-less remains                genuine artistic sensibility with 
flat-busted for reasons that are      all the usual struggles with 
never very well articulated.          practicality that often goes with it. 
 
                                      Hypothetically he could cruise 
   Primarily these books              through a junk auction and pick 
   work as vehicles for               up some great deals, but in 
   the display of British             practice he can't maintain the 
   slang and the display              necessary poker face. 
   of esoterica 
   concerning the                     He supposedly has an unparalleled 
   antiques trade.                    ability to fake antiques, but it 
                                      would seem that he can't make 
                                      them fast enough to make much 
                                      money at it -- he insists on 
                                      using the same techniques that       
                                      the ancient masters did --           
                                                                           


Anyway:

p.129

    "Modern forgers get me down.  They won't experiment.
    Worst of all, fakers today don't bother to learn.   
    Like trying to write yet another sequel to 'Pride   
    and Prejudice' without having read the original --  
    though that's been done often enough, God knows."


p.224

   'Well everybody nowadays pretends that
   T.S. Eliot wrote the _The Waste Land_,              
   that he didn't knick it from whatsisname --         (A bit of an exaggeration 
   Madison Cawein, the assistant cashier in            really... but Cawein did 
   that Cincinnati snooker hall. But he did.'          write a poem of the same 
                                                       title with some striking 
                                                       similarities...)

That's the sort of thing you                                     
read a Lovejoy book for.                                              
                                       The other thing might be to       
                                       try to puzzle out Lovejoy's    
                                       character: is he at all      
                                       plausible?  Shouldn't he be a    
                                       *little* better off than       
                                       flat-busted?                   
                                                   
                                              Can't he find         
                                              any way to            
                                              pick-up spare         
                                              change?               
                                                                    
                                              e.g. doing lectures on
                                              antiques?             
                                                                    
                                              Or charge *in advance*
                                              for doing a scan?     
                                                                    
                                                 And does it make sense    
                                                 that women keep falling   
                                                 all over him?             
                                                                           
                                             
                                      Well yeah, maybe it does a little... 
                                      it isn't just a harem fantasy, it's a 
                                      commentary on the poor judgement many 
                                      women show with men -- Lovejoy is so 
                                      obviously useless, and yet women won't 
                                      leave him alone. 
 
 
                                                       


This is a book I may very well have
read already (The Jonno Rant stuff       (I found this on the   
seems a little familiar), not that       shelves of a friend's  
it matters all that much.                place in Bali,         
                                         presumably abandoned   
   As is often the case with             by some other traveler.)
   the later Lovejoy's (and   
   maybe some of the earlier),
   this book is a very woozy  
   mess of too many characters
   and some very incoherent          
   poorly motivated action).         
                             
           SPOILERS                    
                             
I mean, okay, so Gesso is still alive,       
he helped fake his own death.  But    
*what for*?  Is this an attempt at              
manipulating Lovejoy to do something?                                        
But what?  Who would expect Lovejoy to                                        
go off on a revenge kick... well maybe 
Gesso would --                               Really, Lovejoy would by now 
                                             have a dark reputation in his 
And is there any particular reason that      local circles: "Do anything you 
Florida would want Jacinto murdered?         want to him, but don't mess 
                                             with one of his friends, or 
And couldn't Gash have managed just          you're very likely to run into 
a little bit of worm-turning in              a peculiar sudden accident..." 
this plot, rather than have Lovejoy 
convieniently rescued twice, once 
by a bad guy, and once by one of 
his many women? 
 
And okay, so the antiques digressions are what drive the 
books... they get a little irritating after awhile, when 
you're looking for a little plot development. 

(Maybe the trouble is simply that Gash doesn't know where
he's going, so resorts to the device of pushing us outside
of Lovejoy's head... maybe Lovejoy Has A Plan, maybe he's
just improvising, but his moves just seem crazy -- like why
call himself Jonno Rant a *second* time?  And anyway, *why*
does Jonno forgive him the second time exactly?  "You did
me a good turn" So?  And that good turn doesn't seem to make
sense... crazy stuff).




--------
[NEXT - A_DOLLS_HOUSE]