[PREV - UGLYBEAUTY]    [TOP]

LESS


                            Dec 2 2003 - Jun 8, 2004

   Usual tag: Homelessness.

   Not clear that it's a *good* tag.      Bum
                                          Street Person
                                          Gutterpunk
                                          Homeless Person
                                          Drug Addict


                             SELF

                   A parameter you can tweak in
                   visualizing what's going
                   on/understanding where
                   commentators are coming from:

        innocent victims      vs.     lazy bums
        of circumstance

                      Primary symptom, people
                      on the street who seem:

          down-and-out                 unpleasant
          and hurting                  undesireables


                      We need to get them
                      off of the streets.


           We need to                   They're making
           help them.                   tourists
                                        nervous.

           They are,                    They're
           after-all,                   bringing down
           human beings.                property
                                        values.          (ha, as if
                                                         that were
                                                         possible in
                                                         SF)


                      Compassion is arguably
                      not what's going on here
                      precisely.

                      If every compassionate
                      liberal in SF invited a
                      homeless person to
                      sleep on their couch,
                      they would all be off
                      of the streets.

                      Whatever it is that
                      we feel for these
                      people, it seems too
                      abstract and
                      unfocused to call it
                      "compassion".

   Myself, I don't even
   claim to have a huge
   amount of sympathy
   for these people.      I've been known to
                          call them "scumzoids"--
   What I do have         So if you think this        Another piece of slang
   though, is a sense     piece seems insensitive,    I've heard: "sketchy"
   of justice: I don't    you should see some of      or "sketch".
   want to see the law    my other stuff...
   cracking the whip                                            Suggesting
   over the heads of                                            "lightly
   the weak and                                                 sketched in",
   defenseless, just                                            like an
   because they          And when you come                      oscillating
   occasionally annoy.   down to it, the                        speed freak?
                         street people
                         annoy people who
                         annoy me a lot
                         more than they      (Maybe I owe
                         annoy me myself.    them for doing
                                             me a favor.)
   It's pretty
   clear that
   the term
   "homeless"
   is favored
   because it        The way the
   absolves          argument against
   them of all       that goes:
   responsibility.
                                  It's just not
   The older                      *that* hard to
   terminology like               survive in
   "bum", has the                 modern America,
   opposite                       even without any   Provided you avoid
   difficulty.                    heavy job          expensive habits,
   "It's all their                skills...          stay off the drugs
   own fault,                                        (including booze)
   they're just                   Many of them       and keep your
   lazy."                         *could* have       spirits up and
                                  gotten their       self-respect intact.
                                  act together
             Is it possible       to avoid their
             to resolve that      condition.            Doing that in
             question in any                            the face of
             sensible way?                              living a
                                                        bottom rung
         (Possibly not.                                 existance is
         The idea of                                    the trick, of
         "Responsibility"                               course.
         has some hidden
         gotchas.)         SELF

   LETTERS_FROM_EARTH




   Other problems (accuracy
   quibbles?)  with the
   category "homeless":

   "Homeless" might include
   someone doing the couch
   tour for six months, or
   perhaps living in a van      These people don't normally make
   on the edge of town while    it into our mental image of the
   holding down a job.          "homeless", though possibly they
                                should.

   Conversely, gutter-punks
   on Haight street may
   return to their parents
   house in Marin every         At first glance, many people
   other week.                  call them "homeless",
                                but if you knew their
                                background story it might seem
                                more complicated than that.

   Similarly you might have
   drug addicts (including
   drunks) hanging around, who
   you might loosely identify
   as "homeless" without
   checking whether they've
   got places to live.

   And there are cases
   like, say, drug dealers
   working on the street,
   that some people might
   look on as a symptom of
   a "bad neighborhood",
   though this has nothing
   to do with "homelessness".



San Francsico has more of the
homeless/bums/unfortunates/scum
on the street that many other
American cities.

        What is
        The Source
        of The
        Problem?

I hear all sorts of answers to this.
Everyone knows, but they all seem to
know something different.

  It's the weather.  They don't
  freeze to death here.

  They're drug burn-out cases,
  hangovers from the sixties.

  They're all mentally ill, but ever
  since Reagan (governor, then president)    Alternately,
  there's been no facilities for them.       "ever since
                                             Proposition 13".


My guess:

  San Francisco is a relatively liberal
  town, and whenever the powers that be          From a source that
  try to pull a Giuliani and get medieval        I believe (but can't
  on the homeless, then a mayor gets             reveal):
  chased out of office.
                                                    One year under
  We (mostly) don't *like* to see street            Giuliani, the death
  people hassled by the cops, so they               tolls for NYC were
  (mostly) don't, so we've got more                 forged.  Many more
  street people.                                    people died than
                                                    were officially
     So if you're feeling all                       reported.
     virtuous that your town
     takes care of the                                 My theory: they
     "homeless", you might                             chased a lot of
     want to look into how                             people out of the
     they've really been                               squats before winter
     "taken care of".                                  kicked in, and let
                                                       them freeze.
     What I think you'll find:
     the politicians knew you                            (I know one
     wanted them to "clean up                            New Yorker
     the streets" (of human                              with a simpler
     trash?), and they also                              theory: They
     knew that you wouldn't                              just killed
     inquire too closely into                            them all.)
     how they did it.


        Many a town has been
        beautified with a
        thoroughly ugly beauty.


                                UGLYBEAUTY

--------
[NEXT - LESS_LESS]